Very good question. It is a little bit out of the expertise of the average lineman. Probably more in the realm of a good Electrical engineer. Usually with something of this sort I try to find a good reference book that I can hopefully understand. Usually the math required in things of this nature are a little bit beyond my ken.
The following are some excerps from a publication from GE that I picked up one place where I worked. It is a manual that is more geared toward Power Transformers or as some refer to them Sub Station Transformers. However the principles still hold true I'm sure. With this and what little I know maybe you can get a little better understanding. Probably someone else will chime in with some more info also.
Here's the GE stuff. " Although this connection delivers three-phase currents which are approximately symmetrical to a three-phase symetrical load, the currents flowing in the high voltage circuit are not equal nor are they 120 degrees apart.
The maximum safe output of the bank operating in this manner is 58% of a 3 pot Wye/Delta bank. The system is grossly unbalanced, both electrostatically and electromagnetically."
Here's what little I know about them. They will parallel with a 3 pot Wye/Delta bank. Done that many times. You can add an additional wing or power pot with out interuption. Done that a few times. Most companies limit their load to about 20 HP total 3 phase.
Here's something else I noticed in this book and I just thought I'd throw it in also as it's interesting. "Units of widely different impedances may be used to form a Y-delta bank without appreciably affecting the current division. Furthermore, there is no danger of excessive circulating currents in the delta, though the ratios are not the same, for these currents cannot be reproduced in the Y and therefore they are magnetizing currents and necessarily very small."
If you wish perhaps you might contact GE about such a book as this. It's not to be confused with the little GE Distribution handbook that is so common everywhere. This small book was compiled by the Power Transformer Department, Pittsfield,Massachusetts. dbrown20
Results 1 to 10 of 76
Thread: Understanding an Open-Delta Bank
07-07-2006, 05:59 PM #1fio1022 Guest
Understanding an Open-Delta Bank
I don't know where else to ask this question and I have been trying to find the answer for a while now(no one seems to know for sure).
I am an apprentice lineman for my local utility company and I'm trying to understand how an open delta bank provides TRUE three phase power.
A regular wye or closed delta bank has three transformers with three phases feeding the primary side, 3 phases in 3 phases out(3 different phase angles).An open delta only has two transformers with two primary feeds.2 phases in 3 out?I don't get it.
Is an open delta bank secondary supplying true three phase power(120 degree phase shift)or is it two phases compensating for the lack of a third.
Just wondering if I am far off track on my thinking...
Any information is appreciated.
07-07-2006, 08:20 PM #2dbrown20 Guest
Last edited by dbrown20; 07-14-2006 at 06:49 PM. Reason: typo/correction
07-07-2006, 09:45 PM #3Banned
- Join Date
- Aug 2002
07-07-2006, 09:54 PM #4
Open Delta is a 3 phase transformer bank using 2 transformers. In essence one side of the secondary Delta is physically missing, however an electrical measurement is still possible across the missing side and so it is 3 phase. It will phase in with a closed delta bank. It is not as efficient as a 3 transformer bank, but saves one transformer. It also can save one conductor on the primary, whether using Wye or Delta primary, which can be a great savings as well. A lighting connection can be used in an open Delta bank. An open Delta connection can be used in an emergency when one transformer of three in a Delta bank is inoperable or burnt out.
No such hook up in a Y secondary is possible, always use three transformers.Have Trampbag, Will Travel
Everyone who comes here brings a little joy.
Some when they come in. Others when they leave.
07-07-2006, 10:50 PM #5Senior Member
- Join Date
- Oct 2005
One large use of open deltas is feeding one small customer that needs three phase while using the lighting pot to feed the remaining customers on a block. This use is the most common I have seen, especially in city areas where pole space is sparse. The lighting pot is usually a larger kva than the power pot since it is feeding many customers and the power pot is only feeding one customer.
07-08-2006, 11:30 AM #6dbrown20 GuestOriginally Posted by Trampbag
Last edited by dbrown20; 07-08-2006 at 03:35 PM. Reason: typo
07-08-2006, 04:52 PM #7hifihaxor Guest
wow dbrown, i never thought about it but you may be right. with a 100kva or larger, with the 4 sec bushings, connect it like parallel except leave one leg unconnected... the common leg is your neutral and ties to the other pots neutral, and theres your 3 wye phases. ive never tried or seen it but it looks like it would work.
anyone have 3 phase txes in one overhead can? we dont use t hem here, but ive seen them in cali.. 3 pri bushings, 4 sec... really weird wheen i first saw one.
swamp is absolutly correct. ive seen banks with a 75 lighting pot and a 10 or 15 wing pot to feed a gas station and a half block of houses... since we have many areas that are mixed use with houses and businesses open deltas are useful. some old neighborhoods (the gables) have open delta residential services... many houses had three phase well pumps, airconditioners and.. elevators!! in practice, the lighting pot is usually larger in a closed delta bank as well, figuring if you have max load on the wind pots, then youll still need some additional capacity to run single phase loads.
cwye/cdelta banks arent used much in miami because of ferroresonance issues, especially on the 23kv areas.. many older industrial areas have them though. for those in the area, my favorite bank is at merrill stevens drydock on nw7ave and north river drive, its a feeder dead end platform bank. closed delta, very old equpiment, alllllll original and still in excellent condition.
i asked my boss once why on cwye/cdeltas the primary neutral is left floating, he said its in an attempt to balance the currents on the primary side.
07-08-2006, 05:40 PM #8Senior Member
- Join Date
- Nov 2005
- franklin county va
we have them
in nc here on the duke system. we call them stack banks, 3 prim,4 sec. ive seen them in 30 kva, 75,150. im sure there are more but when they go bad we trade them out for 3 pot banks.
07-08-2006, 06:19 PM #9Banned
Originally Posted by hifihaxor
- Join Date
- Aug 2002
In the event of a phase loss the transformer bank will try to replace the missing phase. Its success in replacing the missing phase will depend on the relative size of the transformer bank compared to the load connected to the circuit past the point of phase loss.
Been there, Done that.
Note. It is not the connection to ground but the connection to the system neutral which is the cause of the issues. This is a fine point as the system neutral is well grounded.
When a primary phase is lost, transformer bank primary fuses frequently blow . Transformers burn out often. When two primary phases are lost, there is a backfeed of current from both unpowered transformers. These voltages will be determined by the connected load past the point of phase loss, but the maximum sum of the two voltages will be the normal voltage. That's when the freezers and refrigerators start burning up.
07-08-2006, 06:29 PM #10dbrown20 Guest
All the info. about open banks being for small 3 phase loads etc. is mentioned in the little GE distb. booklet so common at all work places. There are a few more little tidbits of info. about them in this book also. Really there is not much technical info. in those little books. Guess they don't figure linemen need to know that stuff. Of course the angular displacement of a 2 pot wye/delta bank can only be 30 degrees or 210 degrees which matches with the closed bank. Therefore paralleling is possible. One of the requirements of paralleling.
I have some data from a place I once worked that goes into ferro resonance. It is only considered to be a nuisance at about 20 KV and up. I have seen it on 34.5 and it was a classic book example. I have noticed some REC's place a grounding cut out hooked to the floater in order to avoid this problem when opening and closing such a bank. This on their 24.9 systems. I notice that the local power co. where I live, builds no 3 pot wye/delta banks on their 34.5 distb. Only open wye/open deltas and wye/wye.
Floating the neutral high side is primarily to prevent the bank from having all ground faults in the vicinity via the ground and the system neutral, from traveling through the pots and damaging one. When grounded to the system neutral the bank will continue to operate without anyone the wiser, although one pot may be dead and the customer never notices. When one of the remaining 2 goes bad then you have 2 pots to change out. Seen this happen a few times. Worked at a municipal once where some dummies floated the high side on a wye/wye 208 bank. This caused so much damage to the customer's equipment that the supt. ordered all banks regardless of hookup, to be grounded to the system neutral. Eventually this caused more problems.
3 phase overhead pots? Yeah, have seen quite a few on military bases. Once again they're illustrated in the little GE book.
An uncommon pot I saw once, at least for me, was a 3 phase 480 Wye/Delta padmount. Had a wild leg of course and I guess the high side was floated insided the thing. I guess if you want a particular thing, someone will build it. dbrown20